At a bus-stop in central Athens, July 2011.

The miracle that lasted just three days

The new rescue plan agreed by the EU on July 21 has not helped to calm the credit rating agencies. To get out of their impasse, the Greeks must change their methods and push forward a development policy, writes an editorialist.

Published on 26 July 2011 at 14:28
At a bus-stop in central Athens, July 2011.

Miracles, they say, last three days. Well, it must be true, because just three days have gone by since the EU summit, and the rating agencies are flaying us alive [on July 25, Moody's downgraded the rating of Greece, which is now only a single notch above default].

You may tell me that one might have expected it. The result was expected, and, I would even add, immaterial. In any event, the decisions made at the summit will be judged on their merits and over the long term, and not over a summer weekend.

Still, I would offer up three observations:

First, the decisions taken at the EU summit are very clear and positive in terms of tackling the sovereign debt and supporting Greece by granting an additional loan. A gulp of fresh air, as they say.

Receive the best of European journalism straight to your inbox every Thursday

Second, it must be said that things are very vague in terms of cutting Greek debt, which, in six months, should exceed 162 percent of GDP – a staggering level. It’s all rather unclear at this stage – and it can’t be otherwise, for from the moment the "voluntary participation" of the private sector was brought into the debt relief package, no one has been in any position to predict how generous each contributor will prove to be.

Third, the ultimate judges of the efforts made by the Greeks are (for better or for worse) the international markets, which we hope to borrow on once again in 2014 – so said Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos. The close interactions between the markets and the rating agencies are known and embedded in the system.

Development, development, development

There is, therefore, no doubt that the general crisis and the unsustainability of the debt will add substantially to the debt burden. But how to reduce debt to sustainable levels?

Right after the EU summit the Wall Street Journal calculated that Greek debt would drop below 100 percent of GDP. The assessment of this newspaper is of particular importance, because it reflects, more than any other newspaper, the views of the markets and rating agencies.

We are talking here about a drop in the order of between 135 to 140 billion euros without any voluntary participation from the private sector. Frankly, to rely on such a hope would be ridiculous.

Where can the drop, then, come from? From development! This means that if, in the equation, we merely increase our GDP, the debt burden will decrease drastically.

That is why the formula remains unchanged: development, development, development. There is no other method, no other way forward.

And so I hope that, in the end, the Marshall Plan from Brussels will not prove to be akin to those investors who show up every summer to buy the PAOK Thessaloniki football team and, in the end, go away without leaving a penny behind.

Brussels Summit

European leaders tangled up in the billions

What was really decided in Brussels on July 21? For some leaders present at the euro zone summit, this is not entirely clear. "They are aware of having signed an agreement, but explanations of the contents differ," notes the NRC Handelsblad. "This is not satisfactory," the Dutch daily concludes. "We should have been able to expect the heads of state and government to inform us unequivocally about the summits they sat at together."

In the Netherlands, for example, the total amount of the new Greek rescue plan has led to confusion. While Prime Minister Mark Rutte announced a rescue plan totalling 109 billion euros, his Italian and German colleagues suggested a total of around 159 billion. According to the NRC, this difference is due to the amount of the banks’ participation, estimated at between 37 and 50 billion, and which is expected to be added to the official funding of 109 billion.

Tags

Was this article useful? If so we are delighted!

It is freely available because we believe that the right to free and independent information is essential for democracy. But this right is not guaranteed forever, and independence comes at a cost. We need your support in order to continue publishing independent, multilingual news for all Europeans.

Discover our subscription offers and their exclusive benefits and become a member of our community now!

Are you a news organisation, a business, an association or a foundation? Check out our bespoke editorial and translation services.

Support independent European journalism

European democracy needs independent media. Join our community!

On the same topic