Report European Citizens’ initiative

A democratic fiasco?

Eventually, European policy makers and MEPs greeted the start of the new European Commission’s term under the leadership of president, Ursula von der Leyen. In September, Von der Leyen mentioned that the priority of the Commission’s team would be to revive Europe’s democracy. However, it might need to break with the past if it plans to achieve.

Published on 4 December 2019 at 15:39

Besides the kick-off of the new European Commission presidency, December 2019 signalled as well the 10th anniversary of the Lisbon Treaty. Among other novelties, the Lisbon Treaty introduced the European Citizens’ Initiative (ECI) into the ranks of European Law. 

The European Citizens’ Initiative officially came into force in 2012. It is a tool that aims at fostering participatory democracy within EU institutions. To do so, it allows citizens to launch a proposal for a legislative change at the European level. 

More specifically, to launch an ECI, citizens must establish a citizens' committee composed of at least 7 EU citizens being resident in at least 7 different member states. Crucially, European Citizens' Initiatives cannot be run by organisations. Nevertheless, the latter can decide to support a given ECI.

Once a citizens committee registers an ECI on the dedicated institutional website, it must await for a confirmation from the EC to start collecting statements of support from citizens. The citizens committees have one year to collect 1 million signatures.

In case of a successful completion of the signature collection process, the European Commission meets the organisers, who, successively, have the opportunity to present their ECI at a public hearing in the European Parliament. Last but not least, the Commission adopts a response outlining what kind of actions it will propose to follow up on a successful ECI. 

However, the European Commission is not bound, in any manner, to follow up with a legislative act on the successful completion of an ECI. This is the main reason why many European citizens and activists have cried out against the European Commission. 

Pablo Sanchez, campaign officer at the European Federation of Public Services and promoter of the Right2Water campaign, one of the few successful ECIs of the past years, shared his personal experience: “We were disappointed with the final result”. “We were told that the Commissionwelcomes our initiative. So they replied positively, but they didn’t follow suit”, he adds.

As figure 1 shows, only 4 ECIs have been successful in terms of completing the campaign by their relative deadlines. Even worse, none of the latter ECIs led to a fully fledged (hard law) legislative initiative in line with the demands coming from the relative citizens’ committees. These data seem to confirm Sanchez’ experience and critical remarks. Figure 2 gives an overview of all the ECI which have been presented since 2012, comprehensive of those who are ongoing (in need of public support).

According to Alberto Alemanno, Jean Monnet professor at HEC Paris and founder of the NGO, The Good Lobby, “the ECI is not citizens friendly as it should be”. “It has also been dissuading many citizens and NGOs from using it. And therefore it should be further reformed in the future”, he argues.

Actually, over the past few years, a new regulation of the ECI has been developed thanks to the inputs from civil society and the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC). It will apply as of 2020. But will it be a game changer?

Podcast

The Grassroots view on citizen initiative

In the second episode of the podcast series The Grassroots View, produced by Bulle Media, we discuss the objectives and prospects of the ECI with VoxEurop’s supervisory board member Alberto Alemanno (Jean Monnet professor in European Law at HEC Paris and founder of The Good Lobby), Antonio Longo (rapporteur of the European Economic and Social Committee on the European Citizens’ Initiative) and Pablo Sánchez (campaign officer at the European Federation of Public Services and promoter of Right2Water).

Listen to the podcast:

Are you a news organisation, a business, an association or a foundation? Check out our bespoke editorial and translation services.

Support independent European journalism

European democracy needs independent media. Voxeurop needs you. Join our community!

On the same topic